You are here
Home > 2026-27 Season >

Josh Norris’ early struggles could point to a larger issue

There was some hope this season that Josh Norris would return to performing more like the goal scorer the Buffalo Sabres thought they were getting when they acquired him. He had a full offseason to recover without rehabbing injuries and would be given opportunities to be an impact offensive player.

As we approach the quarter mark of the season, he hasn’t come close to being that. The 27-year-old has four goals and seven points in 20 games. That puts him on pace for 17 goals and 29 points in an 84-game season. That’s not close to good enough for the team’s highest-paid forward.

I wanted to dive into what has happened with Norris not only this season, but also the trends in his numbers that point to a larger possible issue.

From Scorer to Playmaker

Norris came to the Sabres as one of the top 40 goal scorers per hour from 2020 to 2024. He was a top-five finisher in goals scored above expected during that period in Hockey Stats model. That skill set, combined with an average two-way game, was supposed to be a top-six center for them for the foreseeable future.

That never truly materialized in Buffalo. Instead, the Sabres got a player who turned into more of a playmaker last season. The way Norris produced in his 44 games last season was good enough when compared against the numbers over a four-year window.

In all situations, the scoring may have been down, but the assists took a significant jump. The microstat data from All Three Zones show a clear shift from the previous campaigns with the Ottawa Senators to how he impacted the game offensively in Buffalo.

Where Did the Shots Go?

All indications are that the Sabres did not ask him to change his game. Norris is now on a four-year trend of declining shooting rates in all situations and at 5-on-5.

Through 20 games, he has a career-low 4.66 shots on goal per hour at 5-on-5. Norris has three games this season with three or more shots on goal. He has three goals in those three games. He has seven games with three or more unblocked shot attempts in all situations. That means that in 65% of the games this season, Norris has had two or fewer unblocked shot attempts.

What’s interesting is that the American-born forward isn’t shooting from worse areas on the ice. In fact, his individual expected goals per hour rate at 5-on-5 has remained consistent at 0.6 over the last four seasons. He’s simply shooting the puck less.

I started looking for reasons why, and I went to the NHL Edge data to see if anything jumped off the page. I found something. This is where my theory began to build: there are signs of a growing issue beyond just playing poorly.

I looked at Norris’ average shot speed over the last five seasons. An alarming trend came to light. You’ll see below that since the 2023-24 season, his average shot speed has significantly decreased.

I should mention that the 2022-23 season is only an eight-game sample, but he was still shooting the puck harder. The color of the bars represents the percentile compared to the league average. The lighter the bar, the lower the percentile.

Why is this significant?

This player has dealt with a shoulder injury and multiple core injuries over the last five years. When you combine this with the shift in playing style and reduction in shot attempts, you have three key data points. Those data points begin to paint a picture of a player changing his game after dealing with injuries.

I’ll add two more pieces of evidence to this theory. Norris had his two career-worst face-off percentage seasons at 49.5% and 50.7% the last two years, respectively. Now, for the first time in his career, he has played a lot of time on the wing.

Scroll back to the microstats. Hits are down, and forechecking numbers are down compared to previous years.

I don’t like to assume when it comes to injuries, but there is a lot of evidence here pointing to this being a thing. It feels like a player who knows he doesn’t have the same shot he did previously. He’s attempting to adjust his game to be impactful and still hasn’t been able to make it work instinctively. There is hesitation in his play, and it’s consistently causing the offense to die on his stick. That starts to play into confidence, and we have a snowball effect unfolding here.

From an on-ice perspective, 5-on-5 is hard because this season has the second-best expected goals rate of the last four years. The on-ice expected goals rate is second-best over that same stretch, and the expected goals against rate is the best of his career this year.

There is some poor luck with the on-ice scoring numbers being among the worst over the last four years at 5-on-5. That said, it ties back to his inability to consistently turn opportunities into offense, which feeds into his on-ice goal numbers at both ends of the ice.

The Sabres essentially have a third-line forward who can be solid defensively and contribute offensively at times. The problem is that player can’t cost you $7.95 million for the next three years. Even in a rising cap world, that’s an inefficient use of cap space.

I don’t know if there’s a good solution here. The best option is to use him, as Ruff had practice lines set up today. Put him in a middle-six role and see if he can give you enough as a defensively reliable forward with some scoring upside. I don’t see a path to a 25 to 30-goal scorer with 50 to 60 points. Unfortunately, I think injuries may have removed that upside.

Then the Sabres will have to decide in the offseason how they want to handle him moving forward. I’m sure it’s a conversation we’ll revisit in the summer.

Data via: Evolving Hockey, All Three Zones, and Hockey Stats
Photo Credit: Bill Wippert/NHLI via Getty Images

Leave a Reply

Top